How Bad is The Fake Review Problem on Amazon in 2024? It's Worse than You Know

Adam E Wilkens

Published:

The world of e-commerce has created new opportunities for businesses to reach more customers and increase their sales. However, the ease of setting up shop and selling products online has led to a growing problem of review manipulation by sellers on Amazon.

Review manipulation is when sellers use tactics to generate more positive reviews for their products, creating an artificial sense of relevance. This can be done in various ways, including offering customers incentives, such as gift cards, for leaving a positive review.

Many sellers rely on Amazon's algorithms to give their products more visibility and higher rankings. If they can generate more positive reviews, Amazon's algorithms will rank their products higher, leading to more visibility and sales.

Unfortunately, it is relatively easy for sellers to manipulate reviews by offering customers incentives, such as gift cards, to leave a positive review. Some sellers will even go so far as to ask customers to leave a negative review on a competitor's product in exchange for a gift card.

This practice has caused a lot of controversy in the e-commerce world and has led to several investigations into the problem. In response, Amazon has implemented several policies to prevent review manipulation.

To protect customer trust, Amazon requires that sellers disclose any incentives, such as gift cards, that were provided in exchange for reviews. Sellers must also inform customers that the reviews they leave should be impartial and honest.

Amazon also has several automated systems to detect and remove reviews that appear biased or have been incentivized. Additionally, Amazon has recently implemented a policy that limits the number of reviews a single customer can leave in a given time period.

Although Amazon has taken steps to prevent review manipulation, sellers continue to find ways to exploit the system. As a result, it is essential for customers to be aware of the potential for review manipulation and to read reviews carefully before making a purchase.

Resources

  1. Amazon's Policies on Review Manipulation

  2. Amazon's Review Guidelines

  3. What is Review Manipulation?

  4. FTC Warns Companies of Review Manipulation

What are Some Common Fake Review Scams on Amazon?

  1. Fake Reviews with Paid Incentives: In this scam, sellers offer customers incentives, such as gift cards, in exchange for a positive review.

  2. Fake Reviews from Fake Accounts: In this scam, sellers post fake reviews to boost their product ratings.

  3. Fake Reviews from Competitors: In this scam, sellers ask customers to leave a negative review on a competitor's product in exchange for a gift card.

  4. Fake Reviews from Family and Friends: In this scam, sellers ask family and friends to leave fake reviews to boost their product ratings.

  5. Fake Reviews from Employees: In this scam, sellers ask their employees to leave fake reviews to boost their product ratings.

To spot fake reviews on Amazon, customers should be aware of several telltale signs, such as reviews that are overly-positive or that use generic language, reviews that don't include specific details about the product, reviews that use the same language as other reviews, reviews that have no photos or videos, and reviews that are posted in a short period.

To help customers spot fake reviews, there are several software programs available that are designed to detect review manipulation.

Some of These Programs Include Fakespot, ReviewMeta, and Fake Review Checker

Fakespot

ReviewMeta

Fake Review Checker

How are Fake Reviews Generated?

Sadly, It mostly comes from desperate shoppers looking to claim a few free bucks. It was not coming from review farms like the old days ten years ago. Sketchy sellers are reverse engineering customer addresses and mailing them postcards that look like this:

IMG_20230202_0001.jpg
IMG_20230120_0001.jpg

Other times sellers insert a card on the packaging with a similar offer. Look for odd QR codes with links to other Quid Pro Quo offers.

People...these reviews are coming hurting the honest review system on Amazon. This has to be stopped. Do not stoop down to the lowest level for $10. You were hoodwinked; instead of taking the seller up on their offer, take action to protect future shoppers.

What to Do If You Bought a Product on Amazon Due to Fake Reviews?

If you have purchased a product on Amazon that you believe has been inflated in popularity due to fake reviews, there are a few steps you can take.

First, you should contact the seller directly and ask for a refund. If the seller does not respond or does not offer a refund, you can contact Amazon and ask for a refund or a replacement product.

You can also report the seller to Amazon by going to the product page and clicking the “Report Abuse” button. This will alert Amazon to the potential for review manipulation and may result in the seller being removed from the site.

Finally, if you have experienced a financial loss from purchasing a product with fake reviews, you can contact your local consumer protection agency and file a complaint. Your complaint may lead to an investigation and potentially a refund.

What Percentage of Products on Amazon have Fake Reviews?

The exact percentage of products on Amazon with fake reviews is difficult to determine, as there is no reliable data source on the subject. However, research suggests that review manipulation is a widespread problem on Amazon, with some reports estimating that as many as 40% of all reviews on the site are fake or manipulated in some way.

Why doesn't Amazon Remove Its Fake Reviews from Its Website?

Although Amazon does have policies in place to prevent review manipulation, they need help to detect and remove all fake reviews from their website. This is because there are many ways that sellers can manipulate reviews without Amazon's knowledge, such as offering customers incentives in exchange for a positive review.

Additionally, it can be difficult for Amazon to detect which reviews are fake or biased, as many fake reviews are written in a way that makes them difficult to distinguish from genuine reviews. As a result, Amazon relies on automated systems and customer reports to detect and remove fake reviews.

What Percentage of Real Shoppers on Amazon Leave a Review?

The exact percentage of real shoppers on Amazon who leaves a review is difficult to determine, as there is no reliable source of data on the subject. However, research suggests that only a tiny percentage of customers leave reviews, with some estimates as low as 6%. This indicates that the majority of studies on Amazon are likely to be fake or manipulated in some way.

What Product Category on Amazon has the Fakest Reviews?

According to a study by the University of Chicago, the product category on Amazon with the fakest reviews is electronics. Write about the University of Chicago study on fake reviews on amazon.

The University of Chicago recently conducted a study on fake reviews on Amazon. The researchers found a large number of fake reviews on the platform, with up to a quarter of reviews dubious. These reviews were often written by people who had a financial incentive to do so, such as the seller of the product themselves.

The study also found that these reviews tended to have a disproportionately positive effect on product ratings. This meant that some products were falsely promoted by reviews, leading to consumers being misled.

The researchers also found that Amazon's algorithms also contributed to the problem, as they often prioritize reviews from verified purchasers, which are more likely to be fake.

The researchers concluded that Amazon needs to monitor reviews better and take more proactive steps to ensure that reviews are honest and unbiased. They also suggested that Amazon should provide more information about the identity of the reviewers to enable consumers to make more informed decisions.

Very sad. Keep your eyes peeled for skeptical glowing reviews, especially when the language repeats itself on an ordinary product seemingly no different than its peers.